I enjoyed Sixth Sense and Unbreakable… But since then I haven’t really enjoyed any of Shyamalan’s movies. They’ve gotten too predictable. You know that whatever you think is wrong, and there’s going to be some kind of twist or surprise in the end. And frequently that you believe to be the main premise of the movie really isn’t. It’s hard to get into a movie when you’re waiting to be told you’re wrong.
So I wasn’t terribly interested in The Happening when it came out. And the reviews that followed up shortly after certainly did nothing to encourage me to see it.
So I don’t really know what posessed Terri to rent it… Especially after we were so thoroughly disappointed by Experiment just the night before (more on that later). But she wanted to see it. She figured if everyone else hated it, when they liked the rest of his stuff, then we would probably like it. Can’t really fault her logic… But logic doesn’t necessarily apply to Shyamalan’s movies.
So… The Happening…
Something weird is happening. People suddently decide to kill themselves in various creative ways. Nobody knows why it happens or who is doing it. Folks think it’s a terrorist attack. So people try to get out of town…only to find that smaller and smaller towns are being attacked… We follow a group of people as they try to find safety from the happening.
I honestly don’t know where to start. There’s so much wrong with this movie. Even if we ignore the blatantly impossible stuff like plants suddenly evolving the ability to emit this horrible neurotoxin, there’s still truckloads of stuff wrong with this movie.
I love how disorganized the non-response is. Folks think there’s a terrorist attack… So they let the kids out of school… And some random people decide to get on trains and busses to leave the city… But there’s no organized evacuation or anything. I didn’t even see any police involvement, emergency services, national guard… Nothing. And then the train just stops in some random town because they lost touch with everyone.
And then everyone is hanging out in a random diner just killing time… Everyone watching the same television programs… And everyone’s content to sit there and twiddle their thumbs until somebody puts two and two together and realizes that they aren’t safe. And then everyone clears out of town in a matter of minutes. And everyone, except for our protagonists, has a car. Even all the people who were on the train with our protagonists. They all leave town in cars, and only two vehicles are nice enough to pause long enough to give our protagonists a ride.
Then you’ve got the idiot who entrusts his daughter to a woman he obviously does not trust, while he goes off to nearly certain death. Good call.
Then you’ve got Shyamalan basically having to explain the premise to us because he can’t come up with a good way to show us. Our protagonists wind up in a car with a couple treehuggers who explain that they think the plants are trying to kill humans. They explain how plants can communicate with eachother and release chemicals and whatever else. The whole premise summed up in a few lines of dialogue. Any possible suspense or wonder immediately wiped away.
So, of course, where do our protagonists go to get away from the killer plants? Why, into the country of course! Leave all that nice, safe concrete behind and go out in the lush, green countryside. Sounds like a great idea to me!
Along the way they run into some other people - random victims-to-be, really. Different folks with various cardboard personalities. A couple annoying kids, a military guy who’s obviously out of his legue, assorted random people trying to find safety. And, of course, none of them do. They all wind up dying, except for our protagonists.
Periodically we’ll get a glimpse of some news program or hear something on the radio… And they keep insisting that they have no idea what is going on, but these things typically peak and then end very quickly. So it ought to all be over soon. I’m not sure how they know that these things typically peak and then end quickly…if they don’t know what this thing is…but they sound certain, and I guess that’s all that matters.
Eventually our protagonists wind up at some cranky lady’s house. I’m not quite sure why they think it is safe to stay there, but they do. So they spend the night… But then she gets a little looney and wants them to leave… But then the toxin gets her and she’s dead… And our protagonists are split up but they can still talk to eachother through a speaking tube…
Now, our scientific hero-guy has already decided that this event is going to come to an end soon, and that they just have to be alive when it is all over. And they seem to think they’re relatively safe inside this crazy lady’s house. So I don’t know why they’d decide to go outside and die together…but they do.
But they don’t die, because the event stopped before they went outside.
And then we fast-forward a few months and things become even less comprehensable - because the entire northwest was basically wiped out, and nobody seems to care. It’s back to business as usual. Literally millions of people dead and the world keeps on turning. Seems to me that folks would want to know what had actually happened, and want to prevent it somehow. Seems to me that there’d be a massive deforestation project or something like that going on. But no, they just kind of sum it all up as an “act of nature” and go on with their lives.
Much like with Signs, I suspect that The Happening was less about the strange events that were advertised to get people into the theater than it was about our protagonists. The key journey doesn’t seem to be a flight from certain doom, but a path to greater communication and understanding in their relationship. The killer plants were just the crisis that pushed them far enough to break down their walls and start talking again.
And, frankly, that annoys me. I really don’t mind going to see a love story with supernatural trappings…but I’d like to be able to make an informed decision. If I think I’m going to see a horror movie, I want a horror movie. If I think I’m going to see a love story, I want a love story. I don’t want to be told I’m going to see one thing, and then wind up with something else once the film starts rolling.
So, yeah… Obviously I was not impressed with The Happening. It was not suspenseful, it was not dramatic, it was not scary or disturbing or disgusting… I was more-or-less bored throughout the movie. If it had just been myself, or if it had been on TV, I certainly would not have watched it through to the end.