After watching Knowing, Terri asked me at what point I realized that the aliens were here to help, rather than hurt.
The aliens are presented as pretty creepy guys… They just kind of stand around, staring… A couple times they pull up outside the house, at one point they’re talking with the kid. Then they show up in his room.
There’s a very strong “strangers with candy” vibe going on. They seem sinister. It seems like they mean to do harm to the protagonists in some way.
Of course we eventually find out that isn’t the case. They aren’t looking to abduct any children… Well, ok, maybe they are. But they’ve got a really good reason.
But, rather than actually answer her question, I wandered off on a tangent. Because I don’t think I would call those aliens terribly helpful. In fact, by any kind of human standards, I’d have to call them criminally negligent at the very least.
These aliens have apparently known about the coming distaster for literally thousands of years. We find out that some of the prophecies in the Bible were actually delivered by these aliens. They’ve apparently been warning people for years, trying to prepare folks for their return visit. Most recently they warned that little girl who wrote those numbers and sealed it into a time capsule.
But, even with thousands of years notice, the best they could do is save a handful of children and relocate them to another planet.
I can accept that maybe the aliens didn’t have the capacity to stop this huge solar flare. Maybe they aren’t that god-like. But they had thousands of years. Literally.
Even if their space ships could only carry a couple kids each… Even if the trip takes a hundred years… They still had time for at least 20 trips. They still could have saved more than a handful of kids.
Or maybe they couldn’t have. Maybe it took them all those thousands of years to get to Earth in the first place… But they still sent those warnings. And by the end of the movie it is obvious that they’re quite capable of communicating complex ideas to the kids. So why didn’t they send a better warning?
That picture we see, the ancient one from some Biblical source, is pretty darn accurate. Obviously the aliens managed to convey a fairly detailed picture of what was going to happen. Why didn’t they say more? Why didn’t they suggest we build a big rocket and lob ourselves out of the solar system? Why didn’t they suggest we start building bunkers miles underground? Why didn’t they send blueprints so we could build our own spacecraft?
Of course it’s just a movie… It’s about an atheist/agnostic guy discovering that there really is more to the universe. And these aliens are really angels. And they’re taking the kids to a modern-day garden of Eden, complete with giant tree of knowledge. I understand all that from a storyline point of view. If the screenwriters had wanted the aliens to do more to save the world, they would have. It’s just a plot device.
But if we suspend our disbelief for a moment, and just live within the context of the movie, it’s fairly obvious that these aliens should have been able to do more than they did. They should have been able to save more people.
If they wanted to.
And that’s the central issue here… These aliens must have had the capacity to do more, but they chose not to. They chose to deliver a string of numbers to a little kid that was going to seal it in the ground for 50 years, rather than deliver the blueprints for a spaceship to some guy working at NASA. It was, ultimately, their choice to let so many people die.
And that, in my opinion, makes them at the very least criminally negligent – if not downright evil.
Which brings me, eventually, to one of my major complaints about any religion claiming an all-knowing and all-powerful god.
If your god is omniscient, then it knows exactly what is going on in the world. Down to the smallest detail. It knows what I had for breakfast, what color underwear I’m wearing, and who killed JFK. It also knows when and where the next terrorist attack is going to take place, or the next murder, or the next rape.
If your god is omnipotent, then it is capable of doing anything and everything it wants to. It can create the entire universe, build a planet, and populate it with humankind. It can raise people from the dead. It can put the image of Mary on a piece of toast. And it can most certainly prevent the next terrorist attack, or murder, or rape.
And yet, terrorists keep attacking. And people keep getting murdered. And folks keep getting raped.
So, obviously, your god chooses to allow this to happen.
Of course we can ramble on about mysterious plans and free will and all that good stuff… But, ultimately, it all comes back to the all-knowing all-powerful god. Because if that god really was all-knowing and all-powerful it could create the very same exact universe, complete with free will and a mysterious plan, but lacking murder and rape and whatever else. All-powerful, right?
So, again, it is the god’s choice to allow these horrible things to happen.
Which, by pretty much any standard makes that god criminally negligent at the very least, if not downright evil.