Last night we watched The Day the Earth Stood Still on Netflix. And today we went to see the new remake of it. Having seen both of them, so close together, I can definitely say that I liked the original much more than the modern remake.
This is not to say that the remake is crap… I thoroughly enjoyed both of them.
Keanu seems born to play the part of Klaatu. His vague, wooden, detached delivery seemed perfect for this stranger in a strange land.
The spacecraft were far more interesting in the remake, and Gort was truly terrifying.
I also much preferred the logic behind the aliens’ actions in the remake.
But, on the whole, I found the original to be a much more satisfying storyline. Largely, I suspect, because if I was Klaatu I would have wiped out the human race as it was presented in the remake.
In the original, Klaatu spends several days on Earth, getting to know the inhabitants. And he never really makes any kind of judgement on humanity… He leaves Earth with an ultimatum – peace or oblivion – and then leaves us to make up our own minds.
In the remake, Klaatu meets with some other alien guy who’s been stationed on Earth for years and has decided that humanity needs to die. Klaatu doesn’t make that decision, humanity doesn’t make that decision, some alien field-agent decides. We don’t know why or how he comes to his conclusion… But he’s pretty sure humanity needs to be wiped out.
Klaatu files his report, kicks off the doomsday device, and goes about his business. He really doesn’t get to know anyone on Earth… Sure, he winds up spending some time with a nice lady and her kid…but it’s a matter of hours, not days. And the humans all around are doing their damndest to kill Klaatu. They just keep shooting at him, and Gort, and his spaceship, and everything else in the general area. Not exactly acting terribly civilized about the whole thing.
Ultimately I didn’t see where Klaatu had any evidence that humanity would actually change. Frankly, I didn’t see where Klaatu had any evidence of anything in particular.
The original movie neither condemned nor saved the human race – it left us with a choice. We, the human race, had to choose whether we could live peacefully or not. It seemed to suggest that we, the human race, could use logic and reason to overcome fears and superstition. It seemed to suggest that we could be more than violent savages.
The remake condemns humanity as a bunch of destructive savages… The choice is out of our hands, the alien field-agent has already made his decision before Klaatu ever arrives. And ultimately we are saved not by our own actions… Not by overcoming our worst tendancies… But because Klaatu has second thoughts.